• Paul Anthony Jones

Thomisticate

(v.) to split hairs, to quibble over unimportant differences



The Thomists were the followers of the philosopher Thomas Aquinas, the thirteenth century Italian scholastic thinker and theologian best known for writing the Summa Theologica, a lengthy instructional treatise on all the theological tenets of the Catholic Church.


The Thomists were known for their disputatious, endlessly incisive reasoning, which often saw them discuss a point under contention by dissecting it down to its absolute minutiae. Aquinas’s Summa Theologica set the brief for this king of reasoning: written in the nine years leading up to his death in 1274, it includes whole chapters discussing ostensibly inane issues like “whether an angel is composed of matter and form?”, “whether an angel can be in several places at once?” and “whether the angels differ in species?” (Aquinas’ style of arguing over what others saw as pointless issues even came to be parodied in an old expression, how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?, which has been used since the seventeenth century to refer to an utterly pointless and time-wasting debate or point of research.)


Among Aquinas’ followers, however, this kind of reasoning was the only serviceable route to true understanding—and as a result, they continued his work in disputing and dissecting subjects down to their most fundamental components. And it’s from there that the verb thomisticate emerged in the eighteenth century.



Seemingly coined by the English clergyman and academic John Lewis in 1730, to thomisticate is to quibble over issues that prove ultimately pointless, or waste your time splitting hairs.


Hi! We’re currently updating the HH blog, including all the tags (below). But with over 700 posts to reformat, well—apologies, this might take a while... 

For now, you can browse the back catalogue using all the tags from the blogposts we’ve already completed; this list will grow as more blogs are brought up to date.

 

Thanks for your patience in the meantime—and any problems or questions, just let us know at haggard@haggardhawks.com.

SUPPORT HH
Buy us a coffee!
CONTACT US
Contact HH directly via email at haggard@haggardhawks.com

© 2021 Haggard Hawks